What is Altitude?

Back by popular demand....

What are the Altitudes?

The concept of Altitude is a radically new approach to development created by Ken Wilber and presented in his book Integral Spirituality. In Holons, we use Altitude as a measure of development in both culture and consciousness. A simple way to explain it is to say that Altitude indicates the degree of developmental unfolding of items such as complexity, consciousness, and the number of perspectives one can take. For example, in consciousness development as indicated below, one goes from the capacity to take only a 1st-person perspective, to also being able to take a 2nd-person perspective, to also being able to take a 3rd-person perspective, and so on. Thus, in this example, you can see that the capacity for love increases (from being able to love only me, to being able to love us, to being able to love all of us, to being able to love all sentient beings....). For convenience, Altitude follows the natural colors of the rainbow, so you'll often hear us refer to degree of development or degree of consciousness or degree of capacity to love, etc. by a particular color of the rainbow (as you will see below).


The occasions in Culture by Altitude are placed on the rainbow in terms of the degree of complexity that they have. In order to communicate effectively, you have to be able to hit the same degree of complexity as the person or persons you’re speaking to. To not make an attempt to adjust your speech to another sentient being is mean, a form of subtle aggression. By learning to spot degree of complexity, you can more effectively communicate and enhance mutual understanding.


We have selected three well-known examples of psychological models to show how easily Altitude can be used to measure them: Abraham Maslow's "Needs," Jean Gebser's "Worldviews," and Clare Graves' "Value Systems." To show the usefulness of Altitude of consciousness, if we say at a given time a person is acting "amber," it means that generally their needs are for belongingness, their worldview is mythic, and their value system is absolutistic. Various cultural events can also be measured by their degree of development or their Altitude—and their movement from one to another as they unfold can also be followed: from archaic (infrared) to tribal (magenta/red) to traditional (amber) to modern (orange) to postmodern (green) to integral (turquoise) to even higher structures that are now evolving, and which we lump together and refer to as indigo. We estimate the Center of Gravity (COG) of a cultural happening (such as a book, movie, etc.) and place it on the Culture By Altitude chart. As always, these colors follow the rainbow and are identical wherever they appear.


Altitude colors measure essentially similar degrees of development wherever you see the same color (e.g. red is always some version of egocentric, self-protective, magical-power—and you know this will be essentially the same whether you're measuring culture or consciousness or capacity for love or capacity for ethics). We often speak of Center of Gravity, for the central part of the action system, whether individual or collective, and the colors are primarily assigned to COG.


(Another revolutionary concept presented in Integral Spirituality is the difference between structures of consciousness and states of consciousness. Altitude applies primarily to structures of consciousness, and those structures generally emerge through a developmental sequence of stages or waves, starting at infrared and unfolding through a rainbow of possibility from there. Many states, however, are available to everyone no matter the Altitude of their COG. States include the three natural states of waking, dreaming, and deep sleep, as well as altered states, peak experiences, intoxicated states, and the entire spectrum of spiritual states, from gross states of oneness with nature, to subtle grace and illumination, to causal formless absorption, to pure witnessing and nondual union with all that is arising. Because most states are ever-present, individuals can have authentic spiritual experiences at any stage or Altitude of development. States and stages, however, are deeply interrelated: research has shown that continued development through stages can help convert passing states into permanent traits, which is one of the more exciting findings of an Integral Approach....)



The Altitudes


Some representative instances of the major colors:


Infrared (archaic—a proto 1st-person perspective): infrared Altitude signifies a degree of development that is in many ways imbedded in nature, body, and the gross realm in general. Infrared Altitude exhibits an archaic worldview, physiological needs (food, water, shelter, etc.), a self-sense that is minimally differentiated from its environment, and is in nearly all ways oriented towards physical survival. Although present in infants, infrared is rarely seen in adults except in cases of famine, natural disasters, or other catastrophic events. infrared is also used as a kind of catch-all term for all earlier evolutionary stages and drives.


Magenta (egocentric—able to take a 1st-person perspective): Magenta Altitude tends to be the home of egocentric drives, a magical worldview, and impulsiveness. It is expressed through magic/animism, kin-spirits, and such. Young children primarily operate with a magenta worldview. Magenta in any line of development is fundamental, or "square one" for any and all new tasks. Magenta emotions and cognition can be seen driving cultural phenomena such as Burning Man, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, or superhero-themed comic books or movies.


Red (ego-to-ethnocentric—able to take a 1st- to 2nd-person perspective): Red Altitude is the marker of egocentric drives based on power, where "might makes right," where aggression rules, and where there is a limited capacity to take the role of an "other." Red impulses are classically seen in grade school and early high school, where bullying, teasing, and the like are the norm. Red motivations can be seen culturally in Ultimate Fighting contests, which have no fixed rules (fixed rules come into being at the next Altitude, amber), teenage rebellion and the movies that cater to it (The Fast and the Furious), gang dynamics (where the stronger rule the weaker), and the like.


Amber (ethnocentric—able to take a 2nd-person perspective): Amber Altitude indicates a worldview that is mythic, and mythic worldviews are always held as absolute (this stage of development is often called absolutistic). Instead of "might makes right," amber ethics are more oriented to the group, but one that extends only to "my" group. Grade school and high school kids usually exhibit amber motivations to "fit in." Amber ethics help to control the impulsiveness and narcissism of red. Culturally, amber worldviews can be seen in fundamentalism (my God is right no matter what); extreme patriotism (my country is right no matter what); and ethnocentrism (my people are right no matter what).


Orange (worldcentric—able to take a 3rd-person perspective): In an orange worldview, the individual begins to move away from the amber conformity that reifies the views of one's religion, nation, or tribe. The orange worldview often begins to emerge in late high school, college, or adulthood. Culturally, the orange worldview realizes that "truth is not delivered; it is discovered," spurring the great advances of science and formal rationality. Orange ethics begin to embrace all people, "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal...." Ayn Rand's Objectivism, the US Bill of Rights, and many of the laws written to protect individual freedom all flow from an orange worldview.


Green (worldcentric—able to take a 4th-person perspective): Green worldviews are marked by pluralism, or the ability to see that there are multiple ways of seeing reality. If orange sees universal truths ("All men are created equal"), green sees multiple universal truths—different ones for different cultures. Green ethics continue, and radically broaden, the movement to embrace all people. A green statement might read, "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all people are created equal, regardless of race, gender, class...." Green ethics have given birth to the civil rights, feminist, and gay rights movements, as well as environmentalism.


The green worldview's multiple perspectives give it room for greater compassion, idealism, and involvement, in its healthy form. Such qualities are seen by organizations such as the Sierra Club, Amnesty International, Union of Concerned Scientists, and Doctors Without Borders. In its unhealthy form green worldviews can lead to extreme relativism, where all beliefs are seen as relative and equally true, which can in turn lead to the nihilism, narcissism, irony, and meaninglessness exhibited by many of today's intellectuals, academics, and trend-setters.... Not to mention another "lost" generation in students.


Teal (worldcentric to kosmocentric—able to take a 4th/5th-person perspective): Teal Altitude marks the beginning of an integral worldview, where pluralism and relativism are transcended and included into a more systematic whole. The teal worldview honors the insights of the green worldview, but places it into a larger context that allows for healthy hierarchies, and healthy value distinctions.


Perhaps most important, a teal worldview begins to see the process of development itself, acknowledging that each one of the previous stages (magenta through green) has an important role to play in the human experience. Teal consciousness sees that each of the previous stages reveals an important truth, and pulls them all together and integrates them without trying to change them to “be more like me,” and without resorting to cultural relativism (“all are equal”).


Teal worldviews do more than just see all points of view (that’s a green worldview)—it can see and honor them, but also critically evaluate them.


Turquoise (kosmocentric—able to take a 5th-person perspective): Turquoise is a mature integral view, one that sees not only healthy hierarchy but also the various quadrants of humans knowledge, expression, and inquiry (at the minimum: I, we, and it). While teal worldviews tend to be secular, turquoise is the first to begin to integrate Spirit as a living force in the world (manifested through any or all of the 3 Faces of God: “I”—the “No self” or “witness” of Buddhism; “we/thou”—the “great other” of Christianity, Judaism, Hindusm, Islam, etc.; or “it”—the “Web of Life” seen in Taoism, Pantheism, etc.).


Indigo (continues and deepens kosmocentric—able to take 6th-person perspective and higher): Evolution and development continues growing, and we have no reason to believe it will stop with the stage that we are at now. We have indicated all of these higher possibilities with the next color in the rainbow after turquoise, which is indigo.



For a more complete discussion of levels and lines of development, and the AQAL model in general, click here for a free PDF.

Also be sure to check out What are the Four Quadrants?, which summarizes the four major perspectives that are intrinsically built into the universe....



Altitude & Maslow

Also relates to grumble theory.

Maslow ans so on

Maslow's pyramid needs from lower needs to realization accomplishement is it really integral? Does it lack a seventh level of conciousness realization known in the Eastern world?

The holon view is complete and incredibly sound!

It takes account of the left and right hemisphere of the brain. The rational and martian aproach and the intuition artistic venusian approach?

Check out the Wise Turtle...

http://www.thewiseturtle.com/hierarchyofneeds.html

It's just kinda cool. She's thinkin' about all that too.

"The concept of Altitude is

"The concept of Altitude is a radically new approach to development created by Ken Wilber"

What!?! It is not a new concept, even in Ken's own writing. It's just a new name for vertical development. This is the kind of hyperbole that tries to hide the fact that there's nothing new coming from Ken and II.

All that II does is redesign and relaunch their web portal every two years.

Trash and Treasure

One level's Jihadist is another level's Troll.

All those suicide bombers can rest peacfully knowing that the empires they disassembled themselves to protest are no longer in power... DOH! WAIT! THEY STILL ARE!!

LOL

Oy vey.

"The concept of Altitude is

"The concept of Altitude is a radically new approach to development created by Ken Wilber"

I had a somewhat similar reaction on first reading this sentence, and immediately I thought that it wasn't necessary to elicit such a 'Hey, wait a minute.' reader response. The entire statement about altitude is of course well written and explained, but if this sounds like hyperbole to enough people, as it does to me, then maybe it isn't worth trying to emphasize some "radically new" nature of it. It doesn't especially matter about my tastes as a reader, but my preference would be for a dryer proclamation, something like, "The concept of Altitude is an approach to development that has been conscientiously elaborated by Ken Wilber as a helpful and esthetically engaging explanation of that special vertical potential of our human nature." Boring? OK.

I posted this comment over

I posted this comment over on the Integral Praxis blog, thought i would repeat it here, since that's what Anonymous did as well.

"What!?! It is not a new concept, even in Ken's own writing. It's just a new name for vertical development." -Anonymous

Do i think Ken's idea of "altitudes" is radically new? Well, considering that the theory itself is completely based off the developmental models of Piaget, Maslow, Gebser, Graves, etc. i would have to offer a resounding NO. In this sense, Ken hasn't brought any genuinely new developmental schematics to the party.

However, i do think that Ken's SYNTHESIS of all these developmental models IS radically new, especially as each developmental stage relates to states of consciousness. Removing gross, subtle, and causal from the top of the ladder, and plotting them against structures of consciousness was a brilliant--and novel--move.

And "Altitude" as a very general (and inherently content-free) barometer of growth, across many different developmental lines, is also unique to Wilber (as far as i know). But if by "Altitude" we mean the concept of depth itself, as the rungs in whatever developmental ladder you happen to be looking at, then of course this concept has been around for a very long time, and Ken has simply decided to use Colorado-centric terminology for it ^_^

"This is the kind of hyperbole that tries to hide the fact that there's nothing new coming from Ken and II. All that II does is redesign and relaunch their web portal every two years."

These types of comments i tend not to respond to, as i think it will always be the case that our detractors will be much more vocal than our supporters. Which is fine as far as it goes, but can be dangerous when it begins to skew people's perspective toward thinking the Integral community is generally disillusioned. So, i will first say--i can totally understand why you would say that "all we do" is relaunch our web portal from time to time. This is true, and is largely because we have simply not been able to get it right, and are constantly exploring new ways to innovate our content delivery to the rest of the Integral community. And believe me--this is one hell of a task in itself, in terms of both transitioning web portals to new technology, as well as simply maintaining and producing content for the sites we already have.

But i do not want anyone thinking that there is nothing else coming from Integral Institute/Integral Life other than our new web portal. Here is a small sampling of some of the projects we are currently developing:

Partnership with Integral Coaching Canada
Partnership with Integral Recovery
Sponsored research in six different academic areas
Developing Integral Ecology book
Developing Integral Life Practice book
Redesigning the Integral Life Practice kit
Developing two feature films (currently in pre-production)

And there are many more i simply cannot think of right now, but will surely be announced in the coming months.

Thanks for the update and...

As a web designer and Internet entreprenuer, I can understand that fact that a website/ portal/ database is never finished and is always a work in progress. I can sense the efforts (behind the curtain) to make it better and I just want to say your progression
(given the ambitious nature and complexity) has been impressive and entertaining. I look forward to all of the projects you mention above and just wanted to say...I can dig it and have!

When does IntegralLife.com go live, dare I ask?

Ev

Possibly the Most Important Work Being Done Anywhere

Corey:

You guys are doing absolutely incredible work!

I generally am suspicious of sweeping generalizations, but I am pretty comfortable saying that the work you guys are doing may be the most important work being done anywhere by anyone today.

It may not be putting food in people's mouths, or ending civil war, but it is presenting the most comprehensive form of understanding "all that is" that I know of in the world. And understanding will help us create a world where we don't have to put food in people's mouths and there are no civil wars to end.

The simple insight into the distinction between states and stages and how states are generally available to any stage is something that very few people grasp. I have several friends who teach at the university level and who have a background in classical philosophy. I cannot describe their "Aha" look after we talked about the quadrants, stages, lines, and how states fit in.

People live their entire lives and have no mechanism to make order out of their experiences (states) or to explain in a meaningful way how human activity at different altitudes fit together.

The world is filled with brilliant people, each of whom is an expert in a particular tree or family of tree.

You guys are the only ones who have taken on the challenge of introducing us to the forest.

Or to put it another way, you guys are leading the way in re-introducing an appreciation of hierarchical depth.

One question: where can I find a comprehensive listing of exemplars from various fields in life that "belong" to various stages? Most of KW's writings (as well as your article on Altitude) give a few references here and there, but I am wondering if anyone has tried to amass a major list of candidates for various categories?

Of course I realize that any such a list would be a rough approximation. And in many cases the categorizations might even seem unfair. But it seems to me that we could really use an exhaustive listing of exemplars.

Any pointers would be greatly appreciated.

Keep up the great work!

Regards, Leonardo

No PDF

I try to dload the PDF. But no PDF at all, only "My Stuff" and possibilities of subscription

Cannot download Integral pdf

Check out if you have current II mebership....

Integral regards......

Terry

To those having problems

To those having problems downloading the "What is Integral?" PDF - the link has been fixed; i apologize for the inconvenience.

Integral thoughts

About altitude. Can some people more easily pass on to higher levels of altitude? Also, are some people just born on a different level, or, do you have to experience every step along the way? I ask because of the vast difference in levels that I see every day. I've lived in 3rd world country for about a year and the "colors" are so interesting to see. Walking side by side are these people living on different levels, its just great. It doesnt always work its all part of the dance.

Thanks for the recommendation...

Yep, thanks to the anonymous commenter for suggesting people check out my "AQAL" hierarchy of needs diagram, with it's pattern of contraction and expansion, moving through self and other, in the physical, emotional, and intellectual elements . I also have a comparison chart that shows how I see Maslow's hierarchy, Integral, Spiral Dynamics, and Elizabet Sahtouris' cycle of life relating to each other. You can see that chart at: http://www.thewiseturtle.com/comparison.html And I've got a more detailed diagram explaining how Ken Wilber's AQAL stages line up with the "AQAL Spiral" that I've discovered. That can be seen here: http://www.thewiseturtle.com/aqalspiral.html

Peace, Love, and Bicycles,
Turil

only one altitude with unhealthy version??

Interestingly enough, Ken's level that he himself calls "Green" is the only level that has an "unhealthy version" presented here. This keeps returning in his circles, and has even become something of a central trait of the theory - the "boomeritis" phenomenon.

This is truly a bias.

We want to see a description of the "unhealthy orange" for example, that you may consider a greater threat to the world today than "unhealthy green". Who is really causing the environmental and global inequality problems ? Green pluralism and multiperspectives?? Or some of the "rational advances" of orange?

all the best

Uncle A

Wilber often mentions that

Wilber often mentions that all altitudes have pathologies at each meme. Unhealthy Orange for example being the contributing factor to enrivonmental problems and using up reasources. The focus on Boomeritis, is because it is the barrier of narcisim that prevents a Green meme making the leap to second tier, Why is this more important to focus on than other pathologies? Because other memes can not see or honour the view of a meme that is not their own (on first tier), so until the pluralists can move up to an integral worldview, dealing with an orange pathology will be more or less impossible. You need to have people who can understand the use of every meme, and put the first tier structures into perspective. Pathological or not, a first tier meme will not be able to relate to another first tier meme without some kind of clash or conflict of interest. Moving from Boomeritis Green to Integral is the first step in dealing with the pathologies all the way down the spiral; Green boomeritis, Orange exploitation, Blue/Red fundamentalism etc.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <img>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options